Home › Forums › Pittsburgh Penguins › Mike Fink: If Crosby Were Traded, Only These 5 Teams Make Sense
- This topic has 7 replies, 5 voices, and was last updated 2 months, 2 weeks ago by
10inchterror.
-
AuthorPosts
-
July 19, 2025 at 8:02 am #17399July 20, 2025 at 12:05 am #17473
10inchterror
ParticipantNope! Not even reading it. Not gonna happen.
July 21, 2025 at 1:00 am #17536Brownsoldier
ParticipantNope! Not even reading it. Not gonna happen.
it was worse than you would think. The rangers…? The LEAFS????
July 21, 2025 at 8:42 am #1755710inchterror
ParticipantGuess they are trying to keep it more interesting than the normal Montreal and Colorado talk. But really the rangers. Now there’s a bad take.
July 21, 2025 at 1:55 pm #17604MacPatty
ParticipantMontreal is the best option from that list. I do think Crosby would fit with Colorado also.
Rangers & Leafs – just don’t see it happening, as I don’t think Crosby really would care to take himself into the mega markets to try to fix teams with issues.
Edmonton – I don’t think Crosby would be inclined to take a trade to Edmonton to help McDavid win a cup. Especially given there is no certainty that McD will be back next season.
Missing from your list:
1. Florida – I have no doubt Crosby would gel with that team and would enjoy the tax advantage and playing with his buddy Marchand chasing a cup. Can Florida offer much of a return?… not really but who knows. Pens could take Lundell & a 1st and improve their odds this year at McKenna.
2. Vegas – Vegas would need to find a taker for Karlsson to make the cap work but they have a couple 1sts they could offer the Pens. Crosby & Stone would be the best, oldest, toughest C/W combo to play against in the league.If I am Crosby, I want to go to a complete team that has some level of grit and two way play, so he can slide in and not have to try to make up for major deficits on the team he is going to. Montreal is the exception to that rule, but I think they are such a long shot it wouldnt have to be cup or bust if Crosby went there like it would be in Toronto.
July 21, 2025 at 3:56 pm #17626amanion77
ParticipantWhy do media types everywhere insist on trying to will a Crosby trade into existence? He’s said repeatedly he wants to finish as a Penguin.
July 21, 2025 at 5:42 pm #17639Bill Meltzer
KeymasterWhy do media types everywhere inVsist on trying to will a Crosby trade into existence? He’s said repeatedly he wants to finish as a Penguin.
Very first paragraph of Mike’s article: “Let’s start with this disclaimer. Sidney Crosby probably won’t be traded. He has a no-trade clause with one year left on his contract, and if he leaves the Pittsburgh Penguins, it’s his own doing. A trade will only happen if he wants one.”
As for Crosby or any other player he wants to finish his career with a certain team, it’s true until proven otherwise. Example: Mike Modano was a Star for life, until he went back home to finish out as a Red Wing. Giroux was a Flyer for life until there was no extension his final contracted year… then he was a Panther (and then Sen as a UFA).
But in Crosby’s case, he probably will be one who does play for just one team.
July 22, 2025 at 1:07 am #1767110inchterror
ParticipantMontreal is the best option from that list. I do think Crosby would fit with Colorado also.
Rangers & Leafs – just don’t see it happening, as I don’t think Crosby really would care to take himself into the mega markets to try to fix teams with issues.
Edmonton – I don’t think Crosby would be inclined to take a trade to Edmonton to help McDavid win a cup. Especially given there is no certainty that McD will be back next season.
Missing from your list:
1. Florida – I have no doubt Crosby would gel with that team and would enjoy the tax advantage and playing with his buddy Marchand chasing a cup. Can Florida offer much of a return?… not really but who knows. Pens could take Lundell & a 1st and improve their odds this year at McKenna.
2. Vegas – Vegas would need to find a taker for Karlsson to make the cap work but they have a couple 1sts they could offer the Pens. Crosby & Stone would be the best, oldest, toughest C/W combo to play against in the league.If I am Crosby, I want to go to a complete team that has some level of grit and two way play, so he can slide in and not have to try to make up for major deficits on the team he is going to. Montreal is the exception to that rule, but I think they are such a long shot it wouldnt have to be cup or bust if Crosby went there like it would be in Toronto.
Crosby centring Marchand on that 3rd line would be the ultimate depth scoring. I would kinda like to see it but just no haha.
-
AuthorPosts
- You must be logged in to reply to this topic.